twitter google

Ratner: Erick Silva DQ Loss At UFC 142 Won’t Be Overturned

Despite Dana White’s insistence that Erick Silva got screwed when referee Mario Yamasaki disqualified him for illegally striking Carlo Prater on the back of the head at UFC 142, the UFC, who served as the regulatory body at the Brazil event, will not overturn the outcome of the fight.

UFC executive vice president of regulatory affairs Marc Ratner issued a statement on UFC.com explaining that it wasn’t the type of decision that could be reviewed. Ratner also announced that the UFC will begin to use instant replay at all international events regulated by the UFC.

“Based on the referee’s verbal warnings and his determination that the blows were intentional and a disqualifying foul, this is not the type of decision that can be reviewed. Therefore, the decision stands. Recently, Zuffa has decided to implement the use of instant replay at all international events that are self-regulated, and to encourage all regulators to consider the feasibility and effectiveness of instant replay in the sport of MMA. While instant replay would not have reversed the call in the Silva-Prater bout, we believe that it could be valuable to referees and the sport in the future.”

While I don’t necessarily agree that Silva deserved to be disqualified, it’s the good to see the UFC going by the book and not overturning the result just because Dana White thought it should be. Conflicts of interest could easily arise with self-regulation, but as long as the UFC plays it straight there shouldn’t be any problems while they work towards their goal of establishing an international federation of mixed martial arts to regulate events across the globe.

Image via Sherdog

  • Matt Silliman

    Although they didn’t listen to Dana and overturn this, Dana will treat this like Silva won.  So ultimately, what’s the difference?  Wikipedia will show this as a DQ loss for silva, but he will get a step up in competition and carry on much like Jones did after the Hamill DQ.

    Personally, I think that initial knee to the body was the beginning of the end.  I saw have him fight Fitch next.

  • http://twitter.com/Warriordave927 warriordave927

    I think the call should have been overturned but that might be because I’m a little biased(I wanted silva to win),but o still think they made the right move,at least in the sense that their overseas commossion arent a bunch of yes men and go with danas word,but I also hope we see silva back in the cage real soon

  • http://twitter.com/Warriordave927 warriordave927

    I think the call should have been overturned but that might be because I’m a little biased(I wanted silva to win),but o still think they made the right move,at least in the sense that their overseas commossion arent a bunch of yes men and go with danas word,but I also hope we see silva back in the cage real soon

  • http://twitter.com/Warriordave927 warriordave927

    I think the call should have been overturned but that might be because I’m a little biased(I wanted silva to win),but o still think they made the right move,at least in the sense that their overseas commossion arent a bunch of yes men and go with danas word,but I also hope we see silva back in the cage real soon

Follow MMAConvert

Fight Cards

UFC Fight Night 57: Edgar vs. Swanson

Event Date: November 22, 2014
Broadcast: TBD

UFC 181: Hendricks vs. Lawler ll

Event Date: December 6, 2014
Broadcast: Pay-per-view, Fox Sports 1, UFC Fight Pass

The Ultimate Fighter 20 Finale

Event Date: December 12, 2014
Broadcast: FOX Sports 1

UFC on FOX 13: Dos Santos vs. Miocic

Event Date: December 13, 2014
Broadcast: FOX

UFC Fight Night 58: Machida vs. Dollaway

Event Date: December 20, 2014
Broadcast: FOX Sports 1, UFC Fight Pass

UFC 182: Jones vs. Cormier

Event Date: January 3, 2015
Broadcast: Pay-per-view, Fox Sports 1, UFC Fight Pass